• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
ACERIS LAW International Arbitration Law Firm

Aceris Law

International Arbitration Law Firm

  • Aceris Law LLC
  • Outstanding Record
  • Competitive Fees
  • Industries
  • Our Lawyers
  • Accolades
  • Jobs
  • News
  • Contact

Can Inadequate Billing Records Invalidate an Arbitration Costs Award?

22/11/2026 by Aceris Law LLC

Winning an international arbitration can prove to be costly for the losing party, especially when the tribunal orders it to pay the successful party’s legal costs. However, what happens when the winning party claims millions in legal fees without providing detailed billing records explaining who performed the work, how much time they spent or why the costs were necessary?

Arbitration Costs ItemizationOn 1 May 2026, the English Commercial Court (the “Court”) considered this question in Genel Energy Miran Bina Bawi Limited v The Kurdistan Regional Government of Iraq [2026] EWHC 1003 (Comm). Mrs Justice Dias dismissed a challenge to an arbitral tribunal’s award of more than USD 26 million in legal and expert costs, despite expressing serious concerns about the limited documentation supporting the claim.[1]

The judgment illustrates why an arbitral costs award may survive judicial scrutiny even where its evidentiary basis is inadequate. It also highlights the importance of the parties’ agreed arbitration rules and the limited circumstances in which English courts may intervene in an arbitral tribunal’s assessment of costs.[2]

Facts

The dispute arose from the termination of two production-sharing contracts concerning oil and gas reserves in the Kurdistan Region of Iraq. The Kurdistan Regional Government of Iraq (the “KRG”) commenced arbitration against Genel Energy Miran Bina Bawi Limited (“GEMBBL”) under the 2020 Arbitration Rules of the London Court of International Arbitration (the “Rules”). The London-seated proceedings culminated in a two-week hearing in February 2024.[3]

On 2 December 2024, the arbitral tribunal (the “Tribunal”) issued a partial final award finding that the KRG had validly terminated the contracts and dismissing GEMBBL’s counterclaim for damages arising from the alleged repudiation.[4]

Following its success in the arbitration, the KRG sought to recover more than USD 35.5 million in legal and expert fees incurred over approximately two and a half years. However, the supporting documentation contained only aggregated information. The KRG provided total fees and hours by category of legal professional, monthly totals for legal fees, and monthly totals for individual experts. It did not identify the time spent by lawyers on specific tasks or allocate costs to individual workstreams. Subsequent submissions provided only broad descriptions of the work undertaken during each month.[5]

GEMBBL argued that the information the KRG provided to support its costs claim was insufficient to permit a properly informed assessment. It relied on Section 63(3) of the Arbitration Act 1996 (the “Act”), which requires a tribunal exercising its statutory power to determine recoverable costs to specify the basis of its assessment and the items of recoverable costs and amounts attributable to them. GEMBBL argued that the Tribunal should instead refer the assessment of costs to the court under Section 63(4).

The Tribunal rejected that argument, concluding that Article 28.3 of the Rules governed the assessment of legal costs. Although it recognised the limitations of the supporting information, the Tribunal considered itself sufficiently familiar with the proceedings to assess the costs claimed.

It ultimately reduced the legal fees by 20% and the fees of one expert by 50%, resulting in an award exceeding USD 26 million for legal and expert fees. Separate awards were made for disbursements and arbitration costs.[6]

The parties had also agreed, through their adoption of the Rules, to exclude appeals on questions of law. However, GEMBBL challenged the legal and expert costs award under Section 68(2)(b) of the Act, alleging that the Tribunal had exceeded its powers by failing to provide the required itemisation.[7]

Issues

The principal question before the Court was whether an arbitral tribunal could validly award substantial legal and expert costs without detailed itemisation of the work performed. More specifically, the Court had to determine whether the requirements of Section 63(3) of the Act continued to apply despite the parties’ agreement to arbitrate under the Rules.

It also had to consider whether any failure to comply with those requirements constituted an excess of powers under Section 68(2)(b), or merely an error in the exercise of a power the Tribunal already possessed.[8]

Holding

The Court dismissed GEMBBL’s challenge.

It held that the Tribunal possessed the power to determine and award legal and expert costs. Even if the Tribunal had failed to comply with the itemisation requirements of Section 63(3), that failure would not constitute an excess of powers under Section 68(2)(b). Instead, it would amount, at most, to an erroneous exercise of an existing power. This distinction was sufficient to defeat GEMBBL’s challenge.[9]

The Court also considered alternative grounds for dismissing the application.

First, Mrs Justice Dias concluded that Article 28.3 of the Rules constituted a complete and independent mechanism for assessing legal costs, displacing the non-mandatory default provisions of Section 63 of the Act.

Second, even if those statutory provisions applied, the Court considered that the Tribunal had sufficiently identified the relevant categories of recoverable costs.

Importantly, Mrs Justice Dias acknowledged that inadequate itemisation could have caused substantial injustice if it had constituted an excess of powers. However, because no actionable excess of powers had occurred, this did not affect the outcome.[10]

Reasoning

The Court’s reasoning turned on four principal considerations.

First, the parties’ agreed arbitration rules determined the applicable framework for assessing legal and expert costs.

The Act recognises party autonomy in determining how arbitration costs are assessed. Under Sections 4 and 63 of the Act, parties may agree on arrangements that displace statutory provisions that would otherwise apply by default.

The Rules distinguish between arbitration costs, which are determined by the LCIA Court, and the parties’ legal and other expenses, which may be awarded by the arbitral tribunal. Article 28.3 of the Rules empowers the tribunal to determine the amount of legal costs on a reasonable basis that it considers appropriate, without being required to follow the costs-assessment procedures of national courts.

Mrs Justice Dias considered that this provision established a complete framework for assessing legal costs. Although agreement to institutional rules does not automatically exclude every non-mandatory statutory provision, Article 28.3 of the Rules addressed the relevant matters sufficiently to displace the default rules in Section 63 of the Act.[11]

Second, an erroneous exercise of power is not the same as exceeding that power.

The Court relied on the distinction established by the House of Lords in Lesotho Highlands Development Authority v Impregilo SpA [2005] UKHL 43. An arbitral tribunal exceeds its powers when it purports to exercise a power that it does not possess. By contrast, a tribunal that exercises an available power incorrectly does not necessarily exceed its powers.

Applying that distinction, Mrs Justice Dias found that the Tribunal undoubtedly had authority to determine legal and expert costs. The dispute concerned how that authority had been exercised, particularly the evidence required to support the costs claimed and the information included in the award. Even if the Tribunal had made a legal error in determining the degree of itemisation required, that would not transform its decision into an excess of powers.

Section 68(2)(b) of the Act could not therefore be used to circumvent the parties’ exclusion of appeals on questions of law.[12]

Third, the Court did not consider the supporting costs documentation satisfactory.

Mrs Justice Dias was highly critical of the KRG’s failure to substantiate its claim with sufficiently detailed records.

The Court considered it particularly unsatisfactory that a claim exceeding USD 35.5 million had not been supported by information allowing GEMBBL to examine the reasonableness of the individual costs incurred. The Tribunal recognised that the KRG’s limited documentation made it difficult to scrutinise the costs claimed. Nevertheless, it considered that its familiarity with the arbitration enabled it to assess the claim and applied reductions to the amounts sought.

The Court also considered the meaning of the requirement to specify the items of recoverable costs under Section 63(3) of the Act. Even assuming that provision applied, Mrs Justice Dias concluded that it referred to the broad categories of recoverable costs, rather than requiring each individual task performed by lawyers or experts to be itemised.

Accordingly, the absence of a detailed breakdown did not establish a failure to comply with that statutory requirement.[13]

Fourth, potential substantial injustice could not justify setting aside the award without a qualifying serious irregularity.

Section 68 of the Act requires a qualifying serious irregularity that has caused or will cause substantial injustice.

Mrs Justice Dias accepted that, had the Tribunal exceeded its powers by failing to provide sufficient itemisation, GEMBBL could have established substantial injustice. More detailed billing records might have led the Tribunal to assess the claim differently and potentially award a lower amount. However, this conclusion was hypothetical. The Tribunal had not committed an excess of powers capable of supporting a Section 68 challenge.

The Court therefore dismissed the application.

Mrs Justice Dias also indicated that, had the challenge succeeded, the appropriate course would have been to remit the costs assessment to the Tribunal with directions concerning the additional information required, rather than to have the court conduct an entirely new assessment.[14]

Conclusion

Genel Energy Miran Bina Bawi demonstrates that a substantial arbitral costs award may withstand judicial scrutiny even where the supporting documentation is inadequate.

For businesses involved in international arbitration, the decision highlights the importance of maintaining detailed legal and expert costs records, requesting appropriate supporting documentation when disputing costs, and considering costs-assessment procedures at an early stage.[15]

The judgment also illustrates the limited scope for challenging arbitral costs awards under Section 68 of the Act. Disagreement with the amount awarded or the quality of supporting evidence does not necessarily establish that a tribunal exceeded its powers. Parties should therefore scrutinise costs claims during arbitration rather than assume that an unfavourable award can subsequently be challenged successfully in court.[16]


[1] Genel Energy Miran Bina Bawi Limited v The Kurdistan Regional Government of Iraq [2026] EWHC 1003 (Comm) [3], [6], [37], [57]-[58], [66].

[2] Id. [37]-[39], [51]-[53], [66].

[3] Id. [2], [11], [37].

[4] Id. [2].

[5] Id. [3]-[4].

[6] Id. [5]-[6]; English Arbitration Act, s. 63(3)-(4); 2020 LCIA Arbitration Rules, Art. 28.3.

[7] Genel Energy Miran Bina Bawi [2026] EWHC 1003 (Comm) [7]; English Arbitration Act, s. 68(2)(b); 2020 LCIA Arbitration Rules, Art. 26.8.

[8] Genel Energy Miran Bina Bawi [2026] EWHC 1003 (Comm) [10]-[13]; English Arbitration Act, ss. 63(3), 68(2)(b).

[9] Genel Energy Miran Bina Bawi [2026] EWHC 1003 (Comm) [40]-[41], [51]-[53], [66].

[10] Id. [38]-[39], [59]-[63].

[11] Id. [20]-[22], [26]-[28], [38]-[39]; English Arbitration Act, ss. 4(2)-(3), 63(1)-(3); 2020 LCIA Arbitration Rules, Arts. 28.1, 28.3.

[12] Genel Energy Miran Bina Bawi [2026] EWHC 1003 (Comm) [40]-[41], [51]-[53]; Lesotho Highlands Development Authority v Impregilo SpA [2005] UKHL 43 [23]-[24], [31]-[32].

[13] Genel Energy Miran Bina Bawi [2026] EWHC 1003 (Comm) [3]-[6], [37], [57]-[61].

[14] Id. [62]-[63], [65].

[15] See id. [37]-[39], [57]-[61].

[16] See id. [40]-[41], [51]-[53], [57]-[61], [66].

Filed Under: Award on Costs, England Arbitration

Footer

Logo Aceris Law white

Providing the Highest-Quality Legal Representation in International Arbitration, Globally

Europe | Middle East | Africa | Asia | Oceania | North America | South America

Languages

© 2014-2026 · Aceris Law LLC · Legal Notice